Apparently, hair makes me Nice.
I was a girl like most Southern girls of the 1980s. I played with My Little Ponies, but spent long rebellious summers in the dirt. I wore skirts when I wanted, but pants and jeans were just as “cute.” My parents never readily furnished Barbie Dolls, but I would not have been denied if asked. I said Ma’am and Sir, and was addressed as sweetie, honey, sugar by strangers. I grew up in a fairly “gender free” household, given a gaggle of girl children and post-hippie parents. It was never suggested that I
couldn’t grow up to be president (or dictator or empress of the universe). But I was never really a woman.
Starting in Junior High I wore baggy boys clothing. Circa a year before high school graduation, I shaved my head. My hair grew out a bit, and off I went to a women’s college. My first two years of college were very insular- I spent the vast majority of my hours in the company of feminist women and a few feminist men. I stopped shaving my legs and armpits. I wore a dress for the last time circa 2002. I wore men’s button downs and ties. To school formals I wore a men’s tux. I dated women. I shaved my head again and kept it short. I was butch, a real good Southern butch
grrl.
But over the past six months I became a Woman. If I had grown up a Woman, perhaps I would not have noticed the subtle ways the world welcomed me into the fold and celebrated my traditional gender. But the past six months have been total shock.
Suddenly, in stores, restaurants, and various civic and social settings, people have begun addressing me with gendered language. “How can I help you, ma’am?” and “This woman is waiting.” Simple,
nes pas? Not quite. It had never occurred to me that over the past 10 years, no one really called me woman or ma’am. In public I was addressed as Sir (despite my large breasts) or spoken to without reference to gender. “How can I help you?” In parking lots and at bus stops, strange men have begun to compliment me and hit on me. Men are holding doors open for me. Strange women strike up conversation in line about husbands, babies, beauty. On a daily basis, my categorization of Woman is assured, noticed, and complimented.
During a visit to Chicago, a friends first question was, “So… how does having long hair affect your gender identity?”
In April I went to a Sister’s wedding. Since most of my community- and family-of-origin had seen me last, I had grown my hair to chin length. I had lost about 30 pounds (due to illness, not efforts at health or vanity). I was wearing make-up. I had my hair dyed and styled. I was wearing women’s clothing. Every Sister, Aunt, Uncle, Cousin, High School Friend, Girl Scout Leader, Church Members, and Person Who Could Speak pulled me aside in excitement to tell me how beautiful, good, pretty, nice I looked. 10 years of family and community-of-origin functions, and perhaps I had received 3 to 5 compliments on my physical appearance.
Most jarring of all, my father told me I looked very nice. Growing up, we showed out for church on Sundays. Nice dresses/skirts/slacks, clean dress shoes, hair done. Every week on the way out the door Daddy would say to each of us in turn, “You look very nice/beautiful/pretty.” This continued into adulthood. When Sisters brought boys home for church in their ill fitting suits, Daddy’s usual comment, “You look very nice” or “You sure do clean up good!” Upon my own transition into primary church attire of men’s button downs, ties, buzzed hair, etc, never, NOT ONCE, was I called nice, beautiful, or pretty by my Father.
For ten years I was not a Pretty Girl, I was not a Nice Woman. I looked like a butch dyke, loved other
dykes in public, and proclaimed my dissent on my body and in my politics. When you are not a pretty girl or a nice woman, you learn to be Other things.
But now I have medium-length hair. I own some well fitting women’s clothing. The world around me has designated me a Pretty Girl and a Nice Woman. I do not want to be either; I’d rather live in the freedom of the margins. Ex says if I shave my head, I’ll get my edge back, my confidence. Do I shave my head in order to be not noticed by the Gender Affirmation Society of
Amerika? Do I shave my head so people will call me dyke, fag, queer instead of honey, ma'am, bitch? How do stereotypically feminine women survive with freedom and self intact? Maybe that is the point. They don’t. I’d rather be Other things. I’d rather be not-Woman. I’m not Pretty and I sure as shit
ain’t Nice.